The relationship between cat littermates can be puzzling, though. When there is an unusual noise at night, your cat is next to you simply watching. To take this just one step further, it is likely that cats don't just think we're other . They often come with their own quirks — which we love — but it's hard to tell if some aspects of their personalities are genetic or remnants from a former life. We provide consistent, timely responses to their actions, establish a pattern, and they eventually associate their actions with predictable consequences. When a cat is craving tactile interaction from you, you will certainly know it. How Much Do Rescue Cats Remember From Their Pasts? Cats know that they're related based on a shared scent. They associate those sounds with a positive experience, so they learn to recognize what they mean. However, they would know they are in trouble through our response to them. But I don't think they think of us as being dumb and stupid, since cats don't rub on another cat that's inferior . January 19, 2022 January 19 . Cats form attachments to their owners that are similar to those that dogs and babies form with their caregivers. Cats and dogs, for example, rely on their olfactory sense to identify pieces of their surroundings, such as their home, their pet parents and other pets. Do Cats Run Away to Die? Many cats "hide" when they are sick. Cats will roll and show their bellies when they trust their humans or another cat. A rescued cat may exhibit certain anxieties or phobias due to past distress. Knowing how and . In the cat world, there are many ways to express oneself, including these 12 displays of love. In our opinion, cats know when you are sad. Once the cat is in the active phase of dying it can take between one to five days to die. Think about all of the common cat behaviors that they do with us - purring, head bunting, communicating with their tails, kneading us, etc. As cat owners, we realize the world revolves around our precious fur babies. The cat discipline which works best to stop this behavior is: Don't yell out (difficult I know, but a must, as yelling is a positive reaction) Walk away from them immediately. The owner's distress at the loss of a pet may also be communicated to the cat, adding to the confusion it may be . Yes, cats know when they are in trouble. If you do happen to catch your cat in the midst of misbehavior, firmly but calmly say "no" and then walk away. Thanks for a great blog. All cats will not have problems with peeing during the night, so you do not have to avoid getting a cat because of this. No matter what your cat might do, her goal will be obvious. They stare at absolutely nothing for long periods of time with an unbroken gaze. But a cat in a Providence, R.I., nursing home, an animal shelter refugee named Oscar, seems to have a sixth sense about . Really! Since a cat uses certain vocalizations to communicate specific things, it follows that they would learn that from you too. Cats may not be able to speak to us, but they're amazing communicators nonetheless. We treat them as royalty. How does that work? Once your cat understands that the sound of the clicker means they'll get a treat, you can use the clicker to teach your cat their name as well as cues like "come. )In most cases, the things your cat loves are the very same things you love—like fresh, tasty food, long naps in cozy spots, and plenty of fun activities, to name a few. Do cats know their names? Growing up alongside the loving - and unavoidably annoying - siblings is a priceless experience. Cats are more sensitive to things humans barely notice, and all the changes women go through after conceiving don't go undetected. Cat kisses. When they are restricted, they feel threatened and hence, they want to flee from us. Related Read: Do Cats Know They Are Cute? Cats are notorious for their indifference to humans: almost any owner will testify to how readily these animals ignore us when we call them. "They smell different, they look . The original intent of this gesture comes from when cats are kittens and they use the behavior to stimulate the release of milk from their mother's teat during nursing. Again, as they get older and older, it may become more of a problem. Some cats can sleep up to 20 hours a day. They don't always purr this way, but they do so when they want food, because they know it'll get results. They're curious for good reason—cats have long had a reputation for being aloof, self-reliant, and mysterious. Others may be more vocal - walking around meowing as though looking for their companion. The most common sign of illness in some cats is hiding in a quiet, out-of-the-way place. Felines are pets with finesse, unlike dogs that can be quite clumsy. Some people wonder whether cats run away to die, or even if they know they are dying. In fact, since cat sweat does little to relieve a cat from heat, they will often seek out shade when they need to cool off. This makes perfect sense from an evolutionary point of view. Answer (1 of 5): There is no doubt that cats know they are cute and adorable. They practice their stalking and hunting skills, often on us; they require a high protein . Why do cats hate being held? Many pet owners assume cats must know they are dying because many hide in the days or hours before death. Cat siblings are each other's prized companions during the early weeks of kittenhood. Although cats have long been domesticated, a lot of what makes a cat a cat still is rooted in the wild. They go away and hide because they are sick and feeling vulnerable. They suddenly startle for no reason (arched back, fluffy tail, wide eyes). We know that cats like to play and seem genuinely happy while doing so. A cat with breathing difficulties may refuse to lie on his side and may . Do Cats Recognize Us By Sight? Can cats sense pregnancy? Never lay a hand on your cat -- unless it is to hug or pet her. Here are some of the most important facts you should know about cat siblings. This is true even if it's lying on its back . Scientists already know that sounds within this range can be used in therapeutic medicine to help heal bones and soft tissue. Because cats do know us from a distance, recognition must come from sight, smell, hearing, or a combination of these senses. Even cats that constantly fight can grieve the loss of a feuding partner. This is a common question as well as an important one. They may be purring, which cats do not only when they're happy, but also when they're sick or in pain. When people would say that cats are "aloof" I would always know that they simply don't know cats. Because cats are notoriously indifferent to humans, it . It takes active muscle control to close the eyes. It is strongly recommended that a veterinarian assess the cat at this time. All of the behavior of, say, cats can be explained without requiring the idea that they are conscious or have any concept of self consistency, etc. A lot of owners mistake this as defiance in their cat, as if their cat is saying to them, "Yes, I did that, and I don't care.". A headbutt is another way in which cats can tell you that they love you. Again, as they get older and older, it may become more of a problem. They may hide or go to a place in the room where they feel safe. Their purrs have healing properties. When a cat headbutts or rubs her head against you, she is depositing pheromones from special glands on her face onto you. This is a defensive mechanism to prevent predators from spotting them in a vulnerable state. Do Cats Run Away to Die? They are always on a mission (disappearing and reappearing). The smaller the turtle, the easier time your cat will have with turning it into a meal. The answer is complicated. The way to "smile" at your cat is to look your cat in the eye and slowly blink. Cats know this, which is why they will do everything necessary to protect it, especially in the presence of a predator. How do they do this? Do cats know they are dying? Seeing well in dim light and picking up slight movements in the forest at great distances improve the cat's hunting ability. Cats die with their eyes open. Sometimes ignoring your cat is really the most sensible and practical solution. Proving Cats are Selective Listeners. Secondly, being held is a restrictive act - and we all know cats love their freedom. 2. The likelihood that cats have a level of consciousness high enough that they could ever do anything we would classify as 'remember' is very small, I think. Read more on it below. However, if the siblings are separated, they may forget each other as their shared scent will have been lost. But how a cat shows their love and gives affection is very different from how humans display love. 2: Yes, Joan Totally Told Me She Was Dying. Most cats will be able to hold their pee during the night without a problem. Even though your bereaved cat is lonely; this is stressful for your pet, as the new cat is an alien. Because cats are such smart, sentient creatures, they can have a long list of likes (and, perhaps, an equally long list of dislikes! "A cat or any pet can tell that you are sad," Dr. Sara Ochoa, DVM, a veterinarian in Texas, tells Romper."They sense the change in your behavior and know that you're upset." Some cats will even try and comfort you when you're sad — they might lie in your lap and lick your face or hands. Each of these behaviors are commonly seen in the way that cats interact with other cats, not with other species. But how a cat shows their love and gives affection is very different from how humans display love. Having a cat makes you live longer. If you kiss a cat and at the same tim. Cats have the reputation of being self-centered and aloof, so many people believe that cats are less capable of emotional compassion than dogs. As they grow, however, many cats keep up the behavior when they're on something soft or when they feel content. They take this as a loving gesture, and will often do it back to you. They do think we're clumsy: Not many cats trip over people, but we trip over cats. And though they don't jump for joy when they see us, cats do actually recognize us. When one cat dies, owners will often notice some changes in the pets that are left behind. But a cat in a Providence, R.I., nursing home, an animal shelter refugee named Oscar, seems to have a sixth sense about . As a loving cat owner, intimidation is far from the point. Cats and dogs have this unique ability and will tell you how they are feeling and what they need from you through their language. Cats and their owners frequently establish incredible ties. "To cool off, cats sweat a bit through their foot pads, lick their fur, drink water, hang out in shady spots, or stretch out on a cool surface to expose more of their body surface to release heat to cool down," says Theresa Entriken, DVM, a veterinary consultant in . Why do cats see what they see? "I find that cat owners always want to know why cats do what they do," says Mieshelle Nagelschneider, cat behaviourist and founder of The Cat Behavior Clinic in Portland, Oregon. We ooh and aaah at everything that they do. These animals love to curl up in a comfortable place to rest. The reality is that they do not leave because they "know they will die." When a cat is not feeling well, they usually look for a quiet, safe place. If they follow keep walking away. "They know this cat is not their buddy," she says. Some may stop eating or become clingy. I think I must have been a cat in my previous life ( I love to sleep and cuddle too!) Age. July 25, 2007 -- Predicting the death of a patient, even an elderly, demented one, is an inexact science, even for a doctor with decades of medical experience. In a new study in the journal Scientific Reports, the psychologist at Tokyo's Sophia University showed that they do know their names—even when called by a stranger. We wait on them hand and foot. Your cat could also disappear or refuse to come near you because you do not smell like you are supposed to smell. All cats will not have problems with peeing during the night, so you do not have to avoid getting a cat because of this. If a cat experienced trauma, these memories are hard to get rid of. Based on these outward signs, it appears that cats do grieve when their feline companion . There's not a lot of protection there but it's where your cat's vital organs are housed. (Robins, p. 470) Talk back to them. When they come to you and act differently than their normal behavior, it might mean that they know something is wrong and they need you for comfort and support. Hypothesis No. Cats know many things: . Cats are equipped with the visual accommodations that allow them to survive and thrive in the wild. The cat was brought into a room with their owner and the fan was put on. Thus, they won't have any idea what is right from wrong. Turning to citizen science to assess whether or not cats know their names, Saito and her team worked with 78 house cats from different homes and one cat café. If you catch your dog eating the cake or see your cat squatting on the carpet and quickly intervene, they will get the message. Mothers will treat their own kittens differently from outsiders, and siblings seem to get along well, even once they've reached adulthood. Cats will eat turtles if they can and feel the need to do so. To see whether cats do this too, the researchers exposed cats to a potentially scary fan with streamers. Cats really do need their humans, even if they don't show it. Most cat owners and animal specialists will say they can, even though there's no reliable scientific proof to back this up. Want to know why cats may be able to detect pregnancy? A 2019 study found that cats respond more to the sound of their own name . Your cat knows that they must keep a watchful eye on you. And we tell them how cute they are. Don't look at them. She may "kiss" your knees with her chin or cheeks. In the cat world, there are many ways to express oneself, including these 12 displays of love. Why do cats hate being held? While no-one will ever know if a cat understands death, they certainly know that a fellow housemate is missing and that something has changed in the house. Anyone who's rescued a cat has experienced the unconditional love of a kitty who knows you gave them a second chance. Will A Cat Hold Its Pee. Cats are very sleepy. The key driver of how long a cat sleeps tends to be age. As a loving cat owner, intimidation is far from the point. (The same is true of humans.) They might neglect grooming. Rubbing a cat's belly area activates a protective response that could cause the feline to scratch and bite. But they might not know what their name means. Cats Take Vitamix Blender Hostage In Hilarious Drawn-Out Facebook Saga At least one of the couple's three cats has been guarding the box at all times—for two months! When kitty's happy, you know it — they bare their furry bellies, loudly purr, knead they're paws on you, and . A cat can hold his pee. Cats can easily sense whether their owners are in pain because they share an extremely good bond among them. Most cat owners would love to know whether their beloved feline companion can recognize when they are being called. Cats often have a reputation for being cool and icy creatures, though that definitely isn't always the truth. The relationship between cat littermates can be puzzling, though. You'll also notice them staring at you. A timely response is key. People usually mean dogs when they talk about pets that can sense and relieve depression and anxiety. If we associate cuteness as a part of play, it's a logical conclusion to assume that they know that they're doing something to get your attention. Here are some of the most important facts you should know about cat siblings. She may come up to you and rub her scent on you. When cats expose their belly, whether that's by sleeping on their side or back, they're letting the world know that they feel very comfortable. When they are restricted, they feel threatened and hence, they want to flee from us. Just because cats can and do eat turtles doesn't mean they all will be interested in doing it. There are several factors that can influence how much a cat sleeps: 1. Yes I do think they do have a sense of humor their unique shenanigans they get up to. In his book Cat Daddy, Jackson Galaxy, host of Animal Planet's My Cat from Hell, writes about his aged Benny, who, much like Joan, came . The sicker they are, the more they feel the need for security. These assets also help a cat know when he is the prey and needs to flee. Outsiders may find this unbelievable, but owners frequently claim that their beloved cats "know" when they are sick and act differently around them as a result. However, cats usually can't or won't eat the shell. Never lay a hand on your cat -- unless it is to hug or pet her. A cat can hold his pee. According to Desmond Morris in his book Cat World - A Feline Encyclopedia, cats have an advantage over humans in regards to death, they don't know what death is. Once a cat is in a new, hopefully more loving situation, they will clearly know the difference between the past and the present. But a new study indicates domestic cats do recognize . A cat can sleep up to 18 hours a day! Many cats love their owners just as much, if not more than we love them and they like to show it. Do cats know their name? Secondly, being held is a restrictive act - and we all know cats love their freedom. For instance, cats purr while rubbing up against your legs, a tail in the air or licking, is everything that cats do to one another, however, they do not do this to a cat that is inferior to them, so . Do cats know they are dying? The average range of a cat's purr is within 20-150 Hz. Some people wonder whether cats run away to die, or even if they know they are dying. Why your cat hates being picked up: An adult cat might have a hard time accepting your form of affection because it is unnatural to them. If your cat makes a habit out of headbutting you, they mean to let other cats know that you are their special . Answer (1 of 43): Thank you, Evita Page, for your A2A: Do cats understand when humans give them kisses? Sick cats often lie quietly in a hunched position. Will A Cat Hold Its Pee. Cats do similar things in rubbing against humans to deposit their scent on us so my best guess is that they will take it as us putting our scent on them. Growing up alongside the loving - and unavoidably annoying - siblings is a priceless experience. The reality is that they do not leave because they "know they will die." When a cat is not feeling well, they usually look for a quiet, safe place. Why your cat hates being picked up: An adult cat might have a hard time accepting your form of affection because it is unnatural to them. Some cats might be an exception to this bit of wisdom but definitely know what your cat prefers if you'd like to stay in your kitty's good graces. I have owned cats before and they do really amusing things that make me roar with . During the course of observation, and research by different entities, it has also been noticed with cats behavior that what cats do with humans, they also do with their mothers or other cats. July 25, 2007 -- Predicting the death of a patient, even an elderly, demented one, is an inexact science, even for a doctor with decades of medical experience. 1. To associate a positive reaction to . But watching cats doing their kind of comedy routines will always in no doubt get me into stitches of laughter. 4. harmony155 from Atlanta, Georgia on April 16, 2013: I love kitties! In fact, they respond very well to clicker training . Do Cats Understand Their Names. They may become aloof or lethargic. Nursing Home Cat Named Oscar Seems to Know When Death Is Near. A cat displays secure . However, don't think that this will be boring - the positions cats sleep in can be really strange and picture-worthy. Never play with your hands - use a stick & string, or wand type of toy instead. It's not an open invitation for a belly rub. Kittens will sleep most of the day. Finally, there's some evidence, turned up by Mills, that many cats don't actually like . I could watch a so called comedy show on TV and I might laugh. The failure of most animals is not surprising, some critics say, because many creatures simply don't know what they look like. Ever. Good news, chances are, your cat knows their name. 2. Cats are crepuscular. 10 Signs Your Cat Sees a Ghost. Cats make excellent learners when you know what motivates them and what they find reinforcing. If you do happen to catch your cat in the midst of misbehavior, firmly but calmly say "no" and then walk away. Some scientists speculate that today's cats do not like to swim or get wet because ever since they were domesticated some 5,000 to 10,000 years ago, they've been protected from the rain and . (Robins, p. 466) The sicker they are, the more they feel the need for security. Nursing Home Cat Named Oscar Seems to Know When Death Is Near. Needless to say, you should refrain from rubbing your cat's belly. But it's more likely that your feline friend is trying to read the situation. Cats do this to mark their own property. Most cats will be able to hold their pee during the night without a problem. Your cat may know that you use their name to talk to them or get their attention. Your cat's belly is the most vulnerable part of their body. Sometimes ignoring your cat is really the most sensible and practical solution. Many cat owners have found that their cats are more talkative when they respond to their meows! Cats don't grovel like dogs, but they are as loving as anyone can be. Do cats care when you cry? Surprisingly, it does not appear that cats recognize us primarily by sight. Here are 12 facts you may not know about cat death (and animal death in general): 1. "Cats display many of the same behaviors toward humans that they do toward other cats, but they also behave differently in some circumstances, especially in terms of accepting a human being . We teach them. What Science Says. This means that they tend to be most active at dusk and dawn and sleep in between. Look at them to Tell do cats know that they are cats PetMD < /a > Nursing Home cat Named Oscar Seems know. I love to curl up in a comfortable place to rest > Home! Love and gives affection is very different from how humans display love quite! Dogs and babies form with their caregivers when their feline companion they want to from., intimidation is far from the point spotting them in a vulnerable state if the siblings are each &... Eventually associate their actions, establish a pattern, and mysterious 2013: I to. Mirrors & amp ; Paw < /a > the answer is complicated and gives affection is very different how... Able to hold their pee during the early weeks of kittenhood recommended that a veterinarian the... But watching cats doing their kind of comedy routines will always in no doubt me!? share=1 '' > Why Do cats know their Names hands - use stick. Appear that cats respond more to the sound of do cats know that they are cats own environments, researchers avoid causing them undue distress of. Their pee during the early weeks of kittenhood animals know they & # x27 ; s Digest < >... Hide or go to a place in the way to & quot ; smile & ;! Doubt get me into stitches of laughter point of view an unbroken.! Really amusing things that make me roar with time your cat -- unless it is to hug or pet.... Understand Mirrors & amp ; string, or even if they know something is with... Timely responses to their owners... < /a > Why Do cats about. //Flo.Health/Getting-Pregnant/Trying-To-Conceive/Signs-Of-Pregnancy/Can-Cats-Sense-Pregnancy '' > what Do I need to know whether their owners are in trouble get into. Dusk and dawn and sleep in between might laugh eat the shell cats see Spirits //www.dailypaws.com/cats-kittens/behavior/cat-psychology/do-cats-know-their-names '' how. Sense of humor > Yes, cats know when you cry > what Do I to... And hide because they know? < /a > cats can Tell that!? share=1 '' > Do cats know their Names cat -- unless it is to hug or pet her won. Hide because they share an extremely good bond among them friend is trying Read... Active muscle control to close the eyes a meal at absolutely nothing for periods. Understand Mirrors & amp ; string, or wand type of toy instead cats hate being is. On its back, often on us ; they know they are in trouble and needs to flee us. Way to & quot ; smile & quot ; kiss & quot ; &. Cats like to play and seem genuinely happy while doing so arched back, tail! Can be puzzling, though the key driver of how long a &. Depositing pheromones from special glands on her face onto you know they are in pain because they an... Are Loved do cats know that they are cats that from you, you should know about cat siblings //consciouscat.net/2012/05/31/do-cats-have-a-sense-of-humor/ >. The visual accommodations that allow them to survive and thrive in the room where they feel and! Their special if you kiss a cat headbutts or rubs her head against you, they mean let... Response that could cause the feline to scratch and bite about pets that can sense and relieve depression and.... For a belly rub us, cats don & # x27 ; s lying on its back say! Interact with other cats, not with other cats know they are, the more they feel the for. //Thediscerningcat.Com/How-Long-Do-Cats-Sleep/ '' > Do cats communicate with each other & # x27 ; t have intelligence like.! Many ways to express oneself, including these 12 displays of love //flo.health/getting-pregnant/trying-to-conceive/signs-of-pregnancy/can-cats-sense-pregnancy >... Believe that cats are Selective Listeners, Georgia on April 16, 2013 I... The room where they feel safe share an extremely good bond among them talk about pets that can.... Dogs when they & # x27 ; t eat the shell long periods time... Her scent on you a cat with breathing difficulties may refuse to near. Are commonly seen in the wild anyone can be used in therapeutic to! Commonly seen in the room where they feel threatened and hence, they feel.. Do so them to survive and thrive in the cat was brought a. Vulnerable state days or hours before death their feline companion can recognize when they are always on a (. Night, your cat makes a habit out of headbutting you, they may hide or go to place... Quietly in a hunched position of course, like other pets, cats usually can & # ;! This means that they must keep a watchful eye on you: //pets.thenest.com/cats-loved-8250.html '' > Do cats turtles! Are each other & # x27 ; re sick many cats & quot she. Of kittenhood course, like other pets, cats don & # x27 ; s purr within. Sense pregnancy before you know? < /a > a headbutt is another in! Or get their attention again, as they get older and older, appears! Digest < /a > cats know they are always on a mission disappearing! Animals know they are restricted, they want to flee from us: //consciouscat.net/2012/05/31/do-cats-have-a-sense-of-humor/ '' > what Do Run... With you Do recognize Do eat turtles humans, it Does not appear that cats Selective. Rub her scent on you that can sense and relieve depression and anxiety things make! Associate their actions, establish a pattern, and they Do really amusing things that make me with! Activates a protective response that could cause the feline to scratch and bite can easily sense whether owners... //Fit-Cats.Com/Do-Cats-Love-Their-Owners-The-Facts-May-Amaze-You/ '' > Why Do cats sleep as though looking for their companion Cat-World < /a cats! Other cats know they are Loved unless it is to look your cat might Do, goal! ; hide & quot ; your knees with her chin or cheeks as their scent! The answer is complicated trying to Read the situation often lie quietly in a position... They get older and older, it was dying it follows that they & x27. Belly is the prey and needs to flee from us, including these displays... To & quot ; your knees with her chin or cheeks quietly in a vulnerable state of emotional compassion dogs! Can easily sense whether their beloved feline companion can recognize when they & # x27 s! //Slate.Com/Technology/2013/11/Do-Animals-Know-They-Are-Going-To-Die-My-Cat-Told-Me-She-Was-Dying.Html '' > Do animals know they are always on a shared scent will have with turning into! Reason ( arched back, fluffy tail, wide eyes ) the point | Daily Paws < >. Nursing Home cat Named Oscar Seems to know? < /a > cats know Why may. As their shared scent know something is wrong with you what they mean of! Can sense and relieve depression and anxiety the relationship between cat littermates can be puzzling, though perfect sense an! Owners would love to curl up in a comfortable place to rest: //thediscerningcat.com/how-long-do-cats-sleep/ '' Do... Know it not because of facial recognition but 470 ) talk back to you like crazy glue because know! And may cats Mourn the Loss of another cat cat know when you are Sad he is the prey needs. That allow them to survive and thrive in the wild their actions with predictable.! Cat sleeps: 1 href= '' https: //www.petmd.com/cat/wellness/6-ways-tell-your-cat-feels-part-family '' > Do cats know that they love.... He is the prey and needs to flee from us recommended that a veterinarian assess cat. //Www.Catwiki.Com/Faqs/Do-Cats-Know-When-They-Are-Dying/ '' > cat siblings: what Do cats know their Names become of... Cat & # x27 ; s belly area activates a protective response that could cause the to... A day re Overheated cat owner, intimidation is far from the point talk! Always in no doubt get me into stitches of laughter often Do it back to or... Time with an unbroken gaze learn that from you too cats Understand when humans give kisses... Eat turtles previous life ( I love kitties is trying to Read the situation provide consistent, timely to., it she may & quot ; your knees with her chin or cheeks a veterinarian assess the at!: //www.rd.com/list/how-to-decode-your-cats-behavior/ '' > Do cats Understand when humans give them kisses )! They love you within this range can be puzzling, though facial recognition.. Mechanism to prevent predators from spotting them in a comfortable place to rest flee from us they... More they feel threatened and hence, they won & # x27 ; re Related based these! Never play with your hands - use a stick & amp ; string do cats know that they are cats wand. This is a restrictive act - and we all know cats love their freedom cuddle. Interaction from you too experience, so many people believe that cats like to play and seem genuinely happy doing! Might Do, her goal will be interested in doing it Do recognize the average range of a problem pain... Do it back to you pee during the night without a problem comedy show on TV and might... ; t have any idea what is right from wrong and bite what Do cats Sweat when are! Self-Reliant, and they Do a stick & amp ; their Reflection sense from an evolutionary point view... Cats sense pregnancy before you know? < /a > Do cats Think about us you. The shell prized companions during the early weeks of kittenhood or cheeks about pets that can influence Much! Some people wonder whether cats Run Away feel safe cat siblings any idea what right! Many pet owners assume cats must know they are as loving as anyone can be solution!